| William Swenson III | 2017 |
| Bryan Simmons | 2016 |
| Matthew Roias | 2015 |
| Matthew Roias | 2014 |
| Bruce Gill | 1993 |
| Bruce Gill | 1992 |
| Brant Bollivar | 1991 |
| Roland G Bourget | 1990 |
| Bruce Gill | 1989 |
| Emile J Rouleau, Jr. | 1988 |
| Louis A Harmon | 1987 |
| Louis A Harmon | 1986 |
| Linwood Maddix | 1985 |
| Ralph Hemmingsen, Jr. | 1984 |
| Johnny Pass | 1983 |
| Damon Swistak | 1982 |
| Louis A Harmon | 1981 |
| Charles Greene | 1980 |
| Edward Collins | 1979 |
| George Doonan | 1978 |
| Robert Jordan | 1977 |
| Raymond A. Birman | 1976 |
| John Sullivan | 1975 |
| Karl L. Friedland | 1974 |
| Walter Trowbridge | 1973 |
| Edward Cotter | 1972 |
| Kenneth G McKenzie, Sr | 1971 |
| Dale Alexander | 1970 |
| Sam Loving | 1969 |
| Gordon Kirby | 1968 |
| Arthur Lundsten | 1967 |
| William Sanderson | 1966 |
| Warren Hoyle | 1965 |
| Harold Riley, Jr. | 1964 |
| Clarence Urquhart | 1963 |
| Stanley Menard | 1962 |
| Jesse Taber | 1961 |
| Frederick Browning | 1960 |
| Donald Robinson | 1959 |
| Frederick Browning | 1960 |
| Donald Robinson | 1959 |
| Oswald Lyon | 1958 |
| Sheldon Morse | 1957 |
| Franklin Nickerson, Jr. | 1956 |
| Ernest Rotenberg | 1955 |
| Roswell Smith | 1954 |
| William A. Spier # | 1953 |
| Robert M Robertson | 1952 |
| Arnold Dahlstrom | 1951 |
| H. Russell Stevens | 1950 |
| Alva Mawbey | 1949 |
| Robert Partington | 1948 |
| Albert Bryant | 1947 |
| Albert Bryant | 1946 |
| C. Bert Meese | 1945 |
| Alfred Grund | 1944 |
| No listing – possibly due to WWII | 1943 |
| Ernest Gilmore | 1942 |
| Kenneth Bell | 1941 |
| George Spatcher | 1940 |
| Maurice Robbins | 1939 |
| Francis Friske | 1938 |
| Oscar Klinke | 1937 |
| John Wilmarthe | 1936 |
| J. Burleigh Moulton | 1935 |
| Thomas Worrall | 1934 |
| Harold Cole | 1933 |
| William Boots | 1932 |
| Clifford Pierce | 1931 |
| Clinton Davis | 1930 |
| William Moehle | 1929 |
| Joseph Williams | 1928 |
| Albert Dumican | 1927 |
| Norman Stone | 1926 |
| Carroll Thacher | 1925 |
| Charles Pullen | 1924 |
| Charles Pullen | 1923 |